The domain Lexcourts.com expired on 2/28/2013 and has since been purchased by another party.
Amazon
Tuesday, 11 June 2013
Thursday, 21 March 2013
clinical trial deaths in 7 yrs: Centre to SC
Clinical Trial deaths in 7 yrs: Centre to SC
Even
as the Drugs and Cosmetics Act awaits penal provisions, the Centre has informed
the Supreme Court that at least 80 people have died due to illegal clinical
trials in the last seven years.
In
an affidavit submitted to the court as per its directive, the health ministry
has said there were 2,644 "serious adverse events" of deaths during
clinical trials during 2005-2012. Of these, 80 have been attributed to clinical
trials, while the other deaths could be due to terminal illnesses or other
life-threatening diseases. Compensation was paid to families of 44 victims till
2011.
According
to the ministry, there were around 12,000 incidents of "other adverse
effects" in this period, of which 506 directly pertained to clinical
trials.
The
existing Act does not have a single penal provision prescribing a jail term for
illegal clinical trials. The Centre has said it is trying to correct the
"deficiency" by replacing the old law with a 2013 amendment Bill.
The
health ministry has said the Bill seeks to expand the responsibility of the
sponsor (firm which conducts the trials), investigator and ethics committee.
The
Bill also mandates complete adherence to the protocols and good clinical
practice guidelines for conducting trials. In case of non-compliance, it seeks
to authorise the Drugs Controller General of India (DCGI) to recommend
rejection of the study as well as suspension and debarment of the sponsor.
Wednesday, 19 September 2012
CLB issues strict norms for notarisation of affidavits
CLB issues strict norms for notarisation of affidavits
Company
Law Board while passing an order in the matter of Shri Rupak Gupta & Others
Vs. M/s. Banaras House Pvt. Limited has taken a very serious note of the
serious breach of duty by Notaries in the capital while attesting affidavits
(like affidavits having blank spaces, non disclosure of the identity of the
person signing the affidavits, notarization in the absence of the deponents and
cases of false impersonation and false identification of deponent. .
In a press release issued by CLB it has been stated that
Justice D.R. Deshmukh Chairman of CLB while deciding the aforesaid petition has
directed the Chief Secretary, National capital Territory of Delhi to initiate
immediate disciplinary action for cancellation of license of Mr. Ashok Kumar,
Notary Public, Chamber No. B-112, BGS Block, Tis Hazari Courts, New Delhi–110
064 and Mr. Dipankar Das, Notary Public, Registration No. 916, 14, Lawyers
Chamber, Supreme Court of India, New Delhi and to send a report to the Company
Law Board of having done so. In one of the cases the notary had even attested
the affidavit of a lady being deposed and signed by a man and indentified as
such.
The Chief Secretary, NCT of Delhi has also further been
directed to issue directions to all Notaries functioning in the NCT of Delhi to
ensure that they shall obtain the signature and full details of not only the
deponents but also the person indentifying such deponent in the Notary Register
and the Notary shall affix his seal and signature on each page of the document/
petition being deposed to in the affidavits.
SC forces RTI info commissions to be headed by judges, CIC freezes
SC forces RTI info commissions to be
headed by judges, CIC freezes
The
Supreme Court on Friday disposed of a writ petition filed two months ago,
opening the floodgates to many more post-retirement positions for high court
and Supreme Court judges and bringing the functioning of the CIC to an abrupt
emergency halt.
The court ruled that information commissions under the Right to
Information Act 2005 (RTI Act) must function with two-member benches, one of
the two members being a high court judge in the case of an information
commissioner’s post, and a high court chief justice or a Supreme Court judge
for the post of chief information commissioner.
It further said that appointments to these posts must be made only
after consulting with high court chief justices and the chief justice of India.
The ruling will take effect prospectively, clarified the bench,
but left several questions of implementation open to doubt.
“Can only hope that the RTI community quickly grasps the
horrifying implications of this judgement soon and moves court quickly,”
tweeted Legally India blogger Courtwitness adding, “still trying to understand
how this case was argued and decided in two months with the government having
barely had a say defending its stand.”
The first disastrous effect of the order is that all RTI hearings
will have to stop till the judicial members are appointed, explained one of the
drafters of the Act Shekhar Singh to Hindustan
Times. The report stated that more than 17,000 pending cases, translating
into a three month waiting period for an RTI appeal-hearing were already in the
docket until August.
Further, appointment of judicial members is not a simple affair, explained
Friday’s report in The Hindu.
To function in two-member benches the Central Information Commission must have
twelve commissioners six of whom must be judicial members, whereas as of now it
has only eight members none of whom are judicial members. So, two present
members will have to be replaced by judicial members.
But there are two riders. First, all members don’t retire at the
same time, and second, under the RTI Act it is “impossible” to remove an
incumbent commissioner.
To add to the complexity, the retirement age for both Supreme
Court judges and chief information commissioners is 65 making it procedurally
impossible to appoint a retired SC judge a chief information commissioner.
The bench of justices AK Patnaik and Swatanter Kumar passed
directions on the public interest litigation of petitioner Namit Sharma who had
challenged the constitutionality of the sections of the RTI Act that lay down
the eligibility criteria for appointment to the posts of chief information
commissioners and information commissioners at the central and state levels.
According to Sharma, the sections were vague and did not provide
specific eligibility qualifications for such appointments, and that it was not
warranted for a person of non-judicial background to perform judicial or
quasi-judicial functions under the Act because it goes against citizens’
constitutional right to equality before law.
Sharma was also aggrieved with the fact that the Act does not
prescribe any mechanism for proper scrutiny and consultation with the judiciary
to ensure that the information commissioners do their job effectively.
However, the 107-page judgement makes no mention of the arguments
of any government counsel opposing Sharma. The petition was filed on 11 July,
and decided on Friday two months later in a “record-time” hearing for a writ
petition, pointed out Courtwitness.
“Strangely there's no mention of vakalat on the part of the
government. Was any counter affidavit filed disputing writ petition,” asked cbcnn_Pillid in a tweet.
Chief information commissioner Satyananda Mishra, himself a
bureaucrat having a non-judicial background, convened an “emergency meeting” of
the Central Information Commission (CIC) soon after the order to understand the
import of the ruling and take legal opinion on its implementation from the law
ministry, reported Mint.
“The court says the ruling is to come into effect prospectively
but we do not know if this means we have to wait until the existing
commissioners retire or the changes will come into effect immediately,” Mishra
told The Hindu.
Wednesday, 6 June 2012
A Gift can't be taken back
The Supreme Court bench of
Justices S B Sinha and H S Bedi, ruled that gifts from parents to children
could not be rescinded later had said two months ago that parents could
disentitle their son from inheritance if he neglected them. Ashokan from Kerala
was gifted land by his mother through a registered gift deed out of “love and
affection” on January 4, 1984. His father followed suit saying it would help
him lead a good family life. But after one-and-a-half years, the parents
cancelled the deeds saying Ashokan had failed to render financial assistance to
the family though he worked in Oman. They were also upset he did not fulfil his
promise to contribute Rs 1 lakh for his sister’s marriage.
Ashokan approached the
trial court seeking quashing of the two documents executed by his parents
through which the gift was cancelled. Despite the breach of promise cited by
the parents, the court ruled that once the gift deed had been executed, it
could not be revoked “by the mere fact that the donor’s feeling towards the
recipient underwent a change”.
The parents had protested
that if the deeds were kept alive, it would be fair to fear that the son would
evict them from their own land. The district
court ruled in favour of the parents saying the son had not taken possession of
the land, nor paid tax, nor mutated it in his name. The Kerala HC upheld this
decision.
Ashokan approached the SC
challenging the HC’s decision. The SC said the gift deeds were executed out of
love and on the ground that the recipient was the son of the donor and to
enable him to live a good life.
“Could the parents now turn around and say he
was to fulfil a promise? The answer must be in the negative. It’s one thing to
say the execution of the deed is based on an aspiration or belief, but another
to say the same constituted an onerous gift,” said the bench. The SC revived
the gift deeds originally made by the parents and said, “Once a gift is
complete, it cannot be rescinded.”
Saturday, 2 June 2012
Cabinet approves reforms in marriage, divorce and adoption laws
The
Central government took some major decisions with regard to the Hindu Marriage
Act, including making divorce easier, in a key Cabinet meeting.
According
to the decision of the Cabinet, the mandatory six-month clause for filing of
divorce will now be waived off on grounds of irretrievable breakdown.
The
new clause also allows one-time settlement instead of monthly maintenance in
case of divorce.
The
redrafted Marriage Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2010 based on key recommendations of
a Parliamentary Standing Committee also allows a woman a share in her husband's
property. The quantum of share will be decided by the court on case-by-case
basis.
The
Marriage Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2010, which was cleared by the Cabinet, also
seeks to give a woman a share in her husband's property.
The
government has accepted the recommendation of the parliamentary committee that
women should have a share in the property of her husband in case of a divorce
but the quantum of share will be decided by the courts on case-by-case basis.
According
to the Cabinet Note, while a wife can oppose a husband's plea for a divorce
under the new "irretrievable breakdown of marriage" clause, the
husband will have no such rights to oppose if the wife moves the court on the
same grounds.
Apart
from this, bringing a big change in the adoption laws, the Union Cabinet has
cleared equal rights for adopted children in custody cases.
According
to the redrafted Bill passed by the Cabinet, adopted children will have rights
on par with biological off springs of a couple in case the parents go for a
divorce.
Thursday, 31 May 2012
Trade Mark
1. What is a trade mark?
A trade mark (popularly known as brand
name) in laymans language is a visual symbol which may be a word
signature, name, device, label, numerals or combination of colours used
by one undertaking on goods or services or other articles of commerce to
distinguish it from other similar goods or services originating from a
different undertaking.
The legal requirements to register a
trade mark under the Act are:
The selected
mark should be capable of being represented graphically (that is in the paper
form).
It should be
capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one undertaking from those
of others.
It should be
used or proposed to be used mark in relation to goods or services for the
purpose of indicating or so as to indicate a connection in the course of trade
between the goods or services and some person have the right to use the mark
with or without identity of that person.
2.How to select a trade mark?
If it is a word it should be easy to speak, spell and remember.
The best trade marks are invented
words or coined words.
Please avoid selection of a geographical name. No one can have monopoly right
on it.
Avoid adopting laudatory word or words that describe the quality of goods (such
as best, perfect, super etc)
It is advisable to conduct a market survey to ascertain if same/similar mark is
used in market.
3. What is the function of a trade mark?
Under
modern business condition a trade mark performs four functions
It
identifies the goods / or services and its origin.
It
guarantees its unchanged quality
It
advertises the goods/services
It
creates an image for the goods/ services.
4.Who can apply for a trade mark and how ?
Any
person claiming to be the proprietor of a trade mark used or proposed to be
used by him may apply in writing in prescribed manner for registration.
The application should contain the trade mark, the goods/services, name and
address of applicant and agent (if any) with power of attorney, period of use
of the mark and signature. The application should be in English or
Hindi. It should be filed at the appropriate office.
5. How to apply for a trade mark in respect of particular
goods or services?
It is provided under the Trade Marks
Act, 1999 that goods and services are classified according to the International
Classification of goods and services. Currently schedule IV of the Act provides
a summary of list of such goods and services falling in different classes which
is merely indicative. The Registrar is the final authority in the determination
of the class in which particular goods or services fall. The
Schedule IV of the Act is annexed at the end of this questionnaire on trade
marks. For detailed description of other goods and services please refer
to the International Classification published by WIPO or contact the local office
for assistance.
6.What are different types of trade marks available for adoption?
-
Any name (including personal or surname of the applicant or predecessor in
business or the signature of the person), which is not unusual for trade to
adopt as a mark.
An invented word or any arbitrary dictionary word or words, not being directly
descriptive of the character or quality of the goods/service.Letters or
numerals or any combination thereof.
The right to proprietorship of a trade mark may be acquired by either
registration under the Act or by use in relation to particular goods or
service.Devices, including fancy devices or symbols Monograms Combination of
colors or even a single color in combination with a word or device Shape of
goods or their packaging Marks constituting a 3- dimensional sign.
Sound marks when represented in conventional notation or described in words by
being graphically represented.
7. What purpose the trade mark system serves ?
It
identifies the actual physical origin of goods and services. The brand
itself is the seal of authenticity.
It
guarantees the identity of the origin of goods and services.
It
stimulates further purchase.
It
serves as a badge of loyalty and affiliation.
It may enable
consumer to make a life style or fashion statement.
8.Who benefits from a trade mark?
The Regd.Proprietor: The Regd.Proprietor of a trade mark can
stop other traders from unlawfully using his trade mark, sue for damages and
secure destruction of infringing goods and or labels.
The Government: The Trade Marks Registry is expected to earn a revenue of
nearly Rs.40 crores during the current year and which is perpetually on
the rise.
The Legal professionals: The Trade Marks Registration system is
driven by professionals and legal and para legal advisors(Agents) who act for
the clients in the processing of the trade marks application.
The
Purchaser and ultimately Consumers of trade marks goods and
services.
Wednesday, 30 May 2012
KARNATAKA RECORD OF RIGHTS
What is Pahani(RTC) ?
Pahani(RTC) is a very important revenue records, as it contains details of land such as owners' details,
area, assessment, water rate, soil type, nature of possession of the Land, Liabilities, Tenancy and Crops grown, etc.
Why is Pahani required ?
Pahani is required for various purposes:
1. To know the genuiness of seller(owner) when land is being purchased.
2. It is required at Sub-Register's office when sale transaction is being done
3. To raise the farm credit / loan from the Bank.
4. Court needs Pahani in case of Civil litigation.
5. For personal purpose."
What does Pahani contain?
Pahani contains valuable data related to piece of Land. It has the following information :
1. Survey Number and Hissa Number of Land.
2. Total Land under the Pahani.
3. Land Revenue details.
4. Land Owner's name with Extents and Khatha Number.
5. The way land is acquired by the owner.
6. Government/Public rights on the Land.
7. Liabilities of the Owners on the Land.
8. Classification of the Soil.
9. Number of Trees.
10. Source of irrigation and area irrigated.
11. Cultivators Details.
12. Utilisation of land under various categories.
13. Details of Crops grown season-wise.
14. Details of Mixed Crops.
How to get the Pahani ?
One can get the signed copy of computerized PAHANI from PAHANI CENTRE, set up at the Tahsildar Office, instantaneously by paying Rs.15.00. If he is unable to come to Taluk office, it can be collected by paying Rs.15.00 to Village Accountant / Revenue Inspector, who inturn will collect computerized PAHANI from PAHANI CENTRE and hand it over.
How is the computerised RTC different from manual RTC ?
There is absolutely no difference in the contents of computerised RTC and manual RTC. However, the computerised RTC is neat and easily readable and understandable as details are printed in the respective Columns.
Further it cannot be tampered easily."
What are the benefits of computerisation to the Public ?
The Public will have lots of benefits from computerisation. The whole process of updation of Land Records will be transparent. The following are the benefits :
a. Farmer can collect his land records related documents from PAHANI CENTRE instantaneously by paying Rs.15.00.
b. Public can request Revenue Department to carry out the mutation on the land as per their transactions and collect the acknowledgement for that.
c. Farmer can come and see the status of 'mutation requested' by him and status of 'mutation-in-process' on his land.
d. At TOUCH SCREEN KIOSK the Public can view the land records documents, status of mutation and various other reports.
What happens if I take manually written RTC in Computerised Taluk ?
Government of Karnataka has issued the order saying that in Computerised taluka, only computer generated RTC's are valid for all legal purposes and that handwritten RTC will not be recognized by Government"
What is Mutation ?
Mutation is a process through which Owner's name or his particulars like liabilities get changed because of some type of transactions. The type of transaction may be one of the following:
1. J-Slip-Sale through registered deed.
2. Inheritance - Change of Ownership because of death of the Owner.
3. Division of Land within the Family.
4. Pledge / Release - Change in liabilities because of loan from bank or
repayment to bank.
5. Court Decree - Based on the Court Order.
6. Alienation - Conversion of land from agricultural to other purposes.
7. Acquisition by Government for Public purpose.
8. Grant of Land by Government to Poor People."
Is there any difference in Land Records Updation Process after Computerisation ?
NO. Updation process of Land Records is same in both Computerised and Manual systems. All the rules of Karnataka Land Revenue Act are followed as it is, in case of Computerised system with some added precautions."
When does the Owner name and his details Change ?
The change in Owner name and his details will take place when one of the following transactions occurs :
a. J-Slip - Sale transaction takes place at SRO.
b. Inheritance - Death of the Owner.
c. Division of Land within Family Members.
d. Court Decree - Order of the court.
e. Grant by the Government.
f. Alienation for non-agricultural purposes.
g. Acquisition by Government.
h. Podi - Division of RTC into 2 or more.
i. Pledge/Release of the Land with / from banks."
How to bring New Owner's name or change the owner's details in the RTC ?
The Owners of the land will change because of purchase transaction, Inheritance, Division, Grant by Government, Court Decree. When one of these takes place, NEW OWNERS should approach the Revenue Department with the required document to incorporate their names. They can request for the same at the PAHANI CENTRE and collect the acknowledgement.
Similarly when loan is taken or repayment is done, to change the liabilities details, Owner can submit the request at the PAHANI CENTRE with required documents."
What is Objection and how to raise it ?
Objection is a complaint about the transaction. That is, if some transaction comes for change of Ownership, to the Revenue Department, before accepting as it is, department serves the notice to the interested parties and puts in the CHAVADI. If anybody feels it is illegal transaction or feels his rights on the land is in trouble, he can raise the Objection. He has to give a written Objection within 30 days from notice served date to Village Accountant / Revenue Inspector / Taluk Office."
When does crop data change in RTC ?"
Crop details will be written on the RTC once or twice in a year, depending upon the seasons. The Crops information will be written by Village Accountant after inspecting the field."
What to do if crops information is wrong in RTC ?
One can lodge a request to change the crop information on the PAHANI at the PAHANI CENTRE / Village Accountant. The same will be changed after " & " verification by Village Accountant / Revenue Inspector."
Tuesday, 29 May 2012
.IN DOMAIN REGISTRATIONS IN INDIA
.IN DOMAIN REGISTRATIONS
IN INDIA
The Ministry of Information
Technology, Government of India, with effect from January 1, 2005 has
liberalized the policies for registration of country code Top Level Domains
(ccTLDs). According to this policy, it will now be possible for the registered
trade mark and service mark owners to register their trade / service marks as
secondary level domain names along with the top level domain name in India
which is .in. It is also possible for the trade mark owners to register domain
names with their trade marks at the third level along with the second and top
level domain name .co.in. To give an example, it will now be possible to
register domain name Yahoo.in and Yahoo.co.in, subject to Yahoo being a registered trade/service mark in India.
In the past, only registrations
were permitted with the secondary and top level domains .co.in. These registrations were only granted to companies having an
Indian subsidiary. These norms have now been relaxed and even entities not
having a presence in India can register these domains.
The Government of India
has also announced a Sunshine Period from January 1, 2005 to January 21, 2005, during which period
registrations shall be granted only to the registered trade mark owners and not
to other parties. After the Sunshine Period, registration shall be opened to the general public.
In order to deter cyber squatters, we highly recommend that
clients apply for registration of domain names in relation to all their
registered trade marks for the country code Top Level Domains .in and .co.in.
To this effect, our charges will be the same what we charge in
relation to new trade mark applications i.e. US$ 210. There shall be an
additional charge of US$ 110, which is the amount payable to the accredited
Registrar as the official fee for registration and subsistence of the
registration for an initial period of 5 years. Should you be interested in
registering these domains, please contact us and we shall provide you with more
details about the registration process.
What to do before signing the Rental Agreement ?
What to do before signing the Rental Agreement ?
HOUSE ON RENT
There is a huge demand for homes on rent. There are a few essential
things that tenants should be aware of before signing on the dotted line. we
helps you with the particulars.
What's included?
It is extremely important to have clarity on the facilities included in the rent. "I agreed to pay a whopping amount of rent assuming that it includes the monthly maintenance and charges for using the club facilities of my high end township. I was in for a shock when I realised that my agreement stated otherwise and there was nothing I could not do much as it was a mistake on my part." laments, Rajdeep Sanghi, a techie staying in Kondapur. Clarity at every step from discussion to the final agreement, it is imperative to track every detail.
Read before you sign
A common mistake we usually make is not to read a contract before we sign. Obtain a copy of any rules and regulations, make sure you go through everything and before you sign the lease, check to see if these are mentioned:
• The beginning and the expiration date
• The rental price and information about your security deposit
• What are the reasons for which your landlord can terminate your lease contract
• Are there any penalties for moving out of your apartment before the expiration date?
• Are there any responsibilities on your head for repairs and such?
• One of the most important things is to check the notice period of written in the agreement and if a lock-in period is mentioned. " Lock in period results in loss of security deposits, so one has to be completely sure of the terms mentioned in the agreement."
Inspect the apartment
The most important thing when you inspect an apartment you plan to lease is not to let the looks deceive you. Look for the "hidden" attributes and if there's any damage ask for it to be repaired otherwise you may be blamed for it later.
Here are a few things to take a closer look at:
• Pipes - be it gas, water or anything else, check for leaks.
• Sink faucets, shower heads and water - make sure water (both cold and hot) really comes out of the faucets and the shower head and it's with a decent pressure. Also the toilet has to flush properly and thoroughly.
• Electricity and appliances should all be working. Check if all the lights or other electric devices are operational.
• Walls and windows. Check the windows to see if they open close and lock properly. Also inspect the walls. The more walls in common (shared with adjoining apartments), the greater the chance of noise from next door.
• Noise. If it's a highly trafficked area you may have problems concentrating and even sleeping.
Know your landlord
It's very important to know some basic information about the landlord. "If it's a management company with thousands of apartments for rent it may be harder to negotiate, but if it's a family and they just need to secure the income each month, you have a green light to close the deal with a small discount" shares Amit. While, renting a house may seem a daunting task, if the essential parameters are kept in mind then shifting to new place can actually be a smooth transition.
What's included?
It is extremely important to have clarity on the facilities included in the rent. "I agreed to pay a whopping amount of rent assuming that it includes the monthly maintenance and charges for using the club facilities of my high end township. I was in for a shock when I realised that my agreement stated otherwise and there was nothing I could not do much as it was a mistake on my part." laments, Rajdeep Sanghi, a techie staying in Kondapur. Clarity at every step from discussion to the final agreement, it is imperative to track every detail.
Read before you sign
A common mistake we usually make is not to read a contract before we sign. Obtain a copy of any rules and regulations, make sure you go through everything and before you sign the lease, check to see if these are mentioned:
• The beginning and the expiration date
• The rental price and information about your security deposit
• What are the reasons for which your landlord can terminate your lease contract
• Are there any penalties for moving out of your apartment before the expiration date?
• Are there any responsibilities on your head for repairs and such?
• One of the most important things is to check the notice period of written in the agreement and if a lock-in period is mentioned. " Lock in period results in loss of security deposits, so one has to be completely sure of the terms mentioned in the agreement."
Inspect the apartment
The most important thing when you inspect an apartment you plan to lease is not to let the looks deceive you. Look for the "hidden" attributes and if there's any damage ask for it to be repaired otherwise you may be blamed for it later.
Here are a few things to take a closer look at:
• Pipes - be it gas, water or anything else, check for leaks.
• Sink faucets, shower heads and water - make sure water (both cold and hot) really comes out of the faucets and the shower head and it's with a decent pressure. Also the toilet has to flush properly and thoroughly.
• Electricity and appliances should all be working. Check if all the lights or other electric devices are operational.
• Walls and windows. Check the windows to see if they open close and lock properly. Also inspect the walls. The more walls in common (shared with adjoining apartments), the greater the chance of noise from next door.
• Noise. If it's a highly trafficked area you may have problems concentrating and even sleeping.
Know your landlord
It's very important to know some basic information about the landlord. "If it's a management company with thousands of apartments for rent it may be harder to negotiate, but if it's a family and they just need to secure the income each month, you have a green light to close the deal with a small discount" shares Amit. While, renting a house may seem a daunting task, if the essential parameters are kept in mind then shifting to new place can actually be a smooth transition.
Beyond the Blame Game: Can Facebook Be Fixed?
Beyond the Blame Game: Can Facebook Be Fixed?
By Laura
DiDio
E-Commerce Times
05/26/12 5:00 AM PT
E-Commerce Times
05/26/12 5:00 AM PT
Facebook's most daunting challenge in both the near and
long term is how to monetize its existing base of users. The obvious answer is
to drive greater advertising revenues. One way to do that is to more closely
track and sell user information and preferences. However, that strategy is
risky and could backfire.
The
honeymoon is over for Facebook (Nasdaq: FB) and Mark Zuckerberg. In fact, it
ended before it began.
Facebook's
long-awaited and much-hyped IPO is just over a week old, and the blame game is
on as the company has lost 16 percent of its value since the initial offering.
Wall Street's take on Facebook has gone from jubilant to jaundiced.
The
stock ended its first full day of trading a week ago Friday at US$38.23,
essentially flat from its $38 opening price. It did manage to set an IPO record
for sheer volume -- 567 million shares exchanged hands.
Investors
hoped for a turnaround, but it hasn't materialized. On Monday, a selloff
prompted the shares to fall by nearly 11 percent, ending at $34.03. The news
worsened Tuesday. The stock sank another 8 percent, trading in the $31-$32
range. By the one-week mark, the picture hadn't improved. The stock closed Friday
at $31.91.
Investors
have been quick to assign blame, and they didn't have far to look. Facebook's
lead banking underwriters, Morgan Stanley (MS), JP Morgan (JPM), and Goldman
Sachs (GS) all slashed their Facebook earnings forecasts in the middle of the
IPO road show, according to Reuters.
The
underwriter analysts cut their estimates after Facebook issued an amended IPO
prospectus, in which it used vague language to state that the number of users
was growing faster than revenue. That was a big red flag. But the worst part of
this story is that the sales slippage was only disclosed to a select few
underwriters and not the public-at-large, who were eager to cash in on what
they thought would be a great deal.

Industry Calls for SEC to Widen Facebook Probe
The
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is already investigating the opening
day glitches that delayed Facebook being traded on the Nasdaq exchange for
about an hour. There are calls for the SEC to widen its probe into why there
was not a full disclosure about Facebook's lower earnings forecast in advance
of the IPO.
The
failure to reveal the sales and earnings slowdown helped make Facebook the
second largest IPO in U.S. history behind Visa (NYSE: V).
Regardless
of any actions by the SEC, the takeaway is this: Zuckerberg and Facebook
executives became instant millionaires, but the average investor lost because
the company was overvalued.
Can
Facebook do anything to reverse its initial slide and avoid a backlash that
could cause it to sink even deeper? The company must at least attempt to live
up to the hyperbole. As a public company with a very high profile, Facebook is
answerable to shareholders and investors.
The
slightest fluctuation in the stock price -- or worse yet, a continued downward
spiral -- will be analyzed and second guessed as witnessed by the headlines and
commentary.
It
is imperative for Facebook to quickly find ways to accomplish the following:
- expand its base beyond its current 900-plus million members by attracting new users internationally;
- monetize and productize its services; and
- build a cogent, compelling and cohesive mobility strategy that includes mobile applications.
Facebook
founder Mark Zuckerberg, who's firmly in charge with 56 percent ownership,
realizes this. That's why he, his executives and engineers engaged in an
all-night "hackathon" at Facebook's Menlo Park, Calif., headquarters
brainstorming ideas to attract new users and coding software that could
potentially enrich the company's coffers.
Investors
will be more anxious than ever to see Facebook's short-term tactical and
long-term strategic plans to grow the company and swell the ranks of the 900
million current users -- particularly in international markets.
Established
competitors like Google (Nasdaq: GOOG) and newcomers like Pinterest will also
be keeping a close eye on Facebook's fortunes. Facebook must move quickly and
decisively to put the billions it made in its IPO to work immediately before
the stock declines further. Zuckerberg must continue to grow the company,
develop new products to sustain and expand profitability, and avoid being a
flash-in-the-pan.
Facebook's Growth Strategies: Organic and by Acquisition
Growth
comes from two avenues: organic, in which companies develop their own
applications and products; and by acquisition, in which they purchase expertise
and immediate credibility and an entrée into new markets. Facebook must do
both.
The
global economic climate remains challenging. Many of the top-tier high
technology firms, including Google, HP (NYSE: HPQ), IBM (NYSE: IBM) and Oracle
(Nasdaq: ORCL), have made large, high-profile acquisitions. Google, for
example, spent more than $10 billion purchasing nearly 200 firms since its 2004
IPO -- plus another $12.5 billion for its acquisition of Motorola, a deal it
just closed after receiving regulatory approval in China.
Facebook's
most notable acquisition to date has been the $1 billion purchase of Instagram,
which makes a mobile photo application.
Fixing Facebook
That's
a start. The type of company Facebook elects to invest in or purchase is
equally important. Mobility is unquestionably one of the most lucrative and hotly
contested vertical markets. As a mobile photo application, Instagram has the
potential to appeal to both consumer and corporate users. And Instagram is also
less likely to fall prey to the fickleness that is so pervasive in gaming
applications, which typically have the greatest appeal among young users.
Facebook
could conceivably ink a deal with a wireless carrier to charge fees to transfer
photos and photo albums on mobile phones and tablets. For Facebook to play
successfully in the big leagues and challenge the likes of Google, it will have
to make targeted acquisitions in the mobility space that will enhance its
current offerings to ensure a continuing, solid revenue stream.
Facebook's
most daunting challenge in both the near and long term is how to monetize its
existing base of users. The obvious answer is to drive greater advertising
revenues. One way to do that is to more closely track and sell user information
and preferences. However, that strategy is risky and could backfire.
Recently,
U.S. automaker General Motors (NYSE: GM) dealt Facebook a blow when it
announced it would withdraw its ads from the social media site. According to
GM, it did not realize the hoped-for return on investment from new car sales.
This
signals that corporate giants still view Facebook as largely a social media
site geared more toward entertainment and games sales. The company also
suffered a recent setback on the consumer games front. CrowdStar, one of its
biggest developers, said last month it would stop making new consumer games for
Facebook. Instead, CrowdStar will now focus on creating mobile games.
Facebook's
ads do not yet support mobile advertising, and its click-through rate is
"under 0.05 percent, about half the average CTR for banner ads across the
Internet, thus earning a grade of B+ compared to Google's A," according to
a recent study from WordStream.
WordStream
founder and chief technology officers (CTO) Larry Kim was openly critical of
Facebook's prospects in an open letter to investors, stating, "So far,
Facebook's advertising platform hasn't kept pace with the explosive growth of
its social network, and it remains to be seen if CEO Mark Zuckerberg even wants
to focus on advertising as a source of revenue."
The
study gave Facebook only a "C" grade for targeting ads, noting that
it earns "no significant revenue" from its mobile applications used
by 425 million people on iPhones and Androids each month.
Facebook
must find a way to turn this around. As the majority stakeholder with veto
power over minority investors, Zuckerberg must convince Wall Street and the
industry-at-large that he and Facebook are more than just a social network
aimed primarily at the under 21-crowd.
Several
critics focused on Zuckerberg's dressed down appearance and his penchant for
wearing a hoodie. The criticisms are not without merit. The late Steve Jobs
could proudly sport his "uniform" of black turtlenecks and black
jeans, but Jobs and Apple (Nasdaq: AAPL) had a proven track record of success
that spanned both the consumer and corporate market segments.
If
Zuckerberg expects Facebook to be taken seriously, he'll have to signal his
intentions by targeting a larger and more diversified customer base.
In
another potential setback for Facebook, game maker Zynga's (Nasdaq: ZNGA) stock
price dropped by 5 percent, perhaps impacted by insider selloffs and dwindling
numbers of users playing the company's staple online games like
"Farmville," "Zynga Poker" and "Draw Something."
There
is no doubt that Zynga has been a cash cow for Facebook, which has helped
propel its popularity. But the social games market is cyclical, and extremely
sensitive to user fads and whims; it is not a reliable source of long-term
recurring revenue.
Zynga's
fortunes are subject to sharp reversals. This trend is reinforced by less-experienced
investors who panic at the first sign of weakness. If one high-technology
bellwether stock performs badly on a given day, it will create a domino effect,
with investors downgrading the entire market sector.
Zynga
could just as easily be back on top next week with a new online social game
that catches the public's fancy and helps spur an advertising boom on Facebook,
but that's not something Facebook can count on.
Diversification
is another element that's pivotal for Facebook's immediate and long-term
success. It must have a strong, variegated portfolio of products and
partnerships.
Wooing
Wall Street and corporate partners, as well as making strategic acquisitions
and investments in mobile and business applications, must be top priorities for
Facebook. The company will also have to respond satisfactorily to any SEC
investigation. Zuckerberg can't move quickly enough. Otherwise, Facebook could
crash and burn faster than the Hindenburg and suffer the blowback from angry
users.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)